NACCO (NC): First Earnings Report as a Standalone Company
Two days ago, NACCO (NC) released its first quarterly results as a standalone company. Yesterday morning, the company had its first earnings call as a standalone company. The stock dropped 10% following these events. I’m not going to write about NACCO each quarter. But, some people asked for my thoughts on the quarter and the stock drop. So, I’ll do it this once.
Overall, the earnings call and the stock drop reinforced my belief that it could take a year or more of NACCO trading “cleanly” as a separate company before it’s well understood by investors. More on that at the end of this post.
First, the earnings release. Here, everything was as expected.
You can – and should – read NACCO’s full earnings release here. These are the items I highlighted:
- “After the completion of the spin-off, NACCO ended the third quarter with consolidated cash on hand of $93.9 million, debt of $58.7 million and net cash of $35.2 million. The cash on hand included a $35 million dividend received from the housewares business prior to the completion of the spin-off.” So, the company now has $5.13 in net cash per share.
- “NACCO’s board of directors will evaluate and determine an ongoing dividend payout rate at its next regularly scheduled meeting in November. When doing so, the board will consider the financial conditions and prospects of NACCO and North American Coal following the spin-off of the housewares-related business.” We’ll see what they decide to start the dividend at. The “financial conditions” are strong. The “prospects” are bleak.
- Not a highlight, but a note: The after-tax numbers are meaningless here because of a very unusual tax timing situation. The company had a 44% tax rate on continuing operations. In the future, I expect the normal tax rate for NACCO as a standalone company will be 23%. So, ignore all after-tax numbers.
- Centennial is NACCO’s consolidated (so NACCO bears all the risk) failed mine: “Centennial will continue to evaluate strategies to optimize cash flow, including the continued assessment of a range of strategies for its remaining Alabama mineral reserves, including holding reserves with substantial unmined coal tons for sale or contract mining when conditions permit. Cash expenditures related to mine reclamation will continue until reclamation is complete, or ownership of, or responsibility for, the remaining mines is transferred.”
- NACCO confirmed that the customer will bear the risks related to the Kemper plant / Liberty mine failure and NACCO will be paid to do the mine closure work: “The terms of the contract specify that Mississippi Power is responsible for all mine closure costs, should that be required, with the Liberty Mine specified as the contractor to complete final mine closure. Should the decision to suspend operations of the gasifier and mine become permanent, it will unfavorably affect North American Coal’s long-term earnings under its contract with Mississippi Power.”
- “…capital expenditures are expected to be approximately $21 million in 2018.”
- “While the current regulatory environment for development of new